Theo Campbell’s Ex Accuses Him of Abandoning Their Son as ‘Challenge’ Star Prepares to Welcome Another Baby with Wife Olivia Kaiser

Theo Olivia sapphire
“Your move, Theo…”

Theo Campbell’s parenting is being called into question as ‘The Challenge’ star prepares to welcome another child with wife Olivia Kaiser.  

As you may know, the former ‘Love Island’ star welcomed his first child, son Aries, with social media influencer Sapphire Yhnell in February 2021. 

A few years later, Theo began dating fellow ‘Challenge’ star Olivia, and in November 2025, Olivia gave birth to their son, Atlas. The parents went on to tie the knot earlier this year and last week, they announced on social media that they’re expecting baby number two (which will be Theo’s third child). 

“Our little family is growing,” the couple’s joint Instagram post read. “What a blessing it is that God has trusted us with another precious little life to love, nurture, protect, and care for. 

“ … I know this journey will come with its own challenges, growing pains, and beautiful moments, but I wouldn’t trade this blessing for anything,” the post continued. 

Days after the husband and wife announced the news of their growing family, Sapphire aired her baby daddy grievances to The Sun UK, allegedly claiming that Theo has been an absent father to their son, Aries. Former ‘Challenge’ star Jemmye Carroll shared the details of Sapphire’s allegations Thursday on social media, while reminding fans that Theo and Olivia reside in Arizona, while Theo’s first child remains in the UK with his mother. 

“ … Well, baby mama number one is claiming that Theo is an absent father– financially and physically,” Jemmeye said. “She is saying that [Theo] does not support her son financially and that he has not seen their son since October of 2025.

“ … [Sapphire] basically just said since [Theo] met Olivia and moved to America and started his new family, he’s essentially abandoned his first son,” she added. 

(According to Theo’s Instagram, he actually saw Aries in December while in New York City.) 

While it doesn’t appear that Theo or Olivia have responded to Sapphire’s recent claims, Theo did fire back earlier this year after Sapphire posted a video to social media in June accusing Theo of cheating on Olivia (among other things). In the video– which was screen recorded and shared to Reddit at the time– Sapphire addressed Olivia directly, telling the ‘Love Island USA’ star, “Your boyfriend, husband, whatever, likes to FaceTime me when you’re not around.”   

“ … [he tells] me he loves me still, misses me, wishes he could marry me, wants to get back with me, all this other sh*t,” Sapphire claimed. “He also said that if he had a time machine, your child wouldn’t exist, and every time he’s come to the UK without you, he tries to f**k me. He also cheated on you numerous time.” 

In her video, Sapphire alleged that Olivia knew about one of the women Theo cheated with, as the woman messaged Olivia about the incident. She then included clips from a FaceTime call with Theo that allegedly took place in January, in which the reality star could be heard discussing his green card and even proposing to Sapphire that they have “five more Aries” together. 

At one point in the FaceTime call, Theo said to his son, “You know daddy will always love mommy,” as well as, “Can you give mommy a kiss for daddy?” He also told his son that he “misses mommy so much.” 

In text included at the end of the video, Sapphire insisted that the FaceTime clips were not edited and even offered to send the recording of her and Theo’s entire conversation to Olivia. She also alleged that Theo was “an alcoholic, druggy, abusive mess,” who has spoken poorly about Olivia behind her back, even calling her “a bad wife.” 

Theo went on to respond to the video, insisting that Sapphire had edited the clips and posted them out of anger. He also made claims about Sapphire’s mental health and alleged that she was the one preventing him from seeing their son. 

“It’s a shame the only person who this affects [sic] is my son and she has used him as a weapon against me this whole time,” Theo wrote, in part. 

Click here to watch the full video that Sapphire posted in June.   

RELATED STORY: ‘The Challenge’ Star Nurys Mateo Calls Out Ex Horacio Gutierrez for Cheating on Her a Year After Their Split 

(Photos: Instagram; TikTok; Reddit) 

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Gemma

If this is true it’s a damn shame. And that little boy will grow up feeling like he wasn’t good enough and was replaced.

Looking at the video Olivia and Sapphire could be related. And I will be honest I believe Sapphire more than I do Theo.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

1
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x