Reason for Micah & Isaac Plath’s Brutal Physical Fight in February Revealed; ‘Welcome to Plathville’ Preview Shows Post-Fight Footage

“I don’t beat up my brother every day…but when I do, I do it right.”

Tuesday’s episode of Welcome to Plathville ended with Lydia Plath and Zac Wyse tying the knot— and Micah Plath’s girlfriend Veronica Peters being revealed as the reason that Micah and his younger brother Isaac got into a brutal physical brawl following their sister’s big day. 

As The Ashley previously told you, the ‘Welcome to Plathville’ stars got into a physical fight back in February. At some point during the Battle of the Blond Bros, Micah’s nose was broken, ultimately requiring him to go the hospital to have his extensive facial wounds tended to. 

Veronica– who broke up with the TLC star shortly after the February Fight Club incident– confirmed the details of the sibling scrap on social media earlier this year, later claiming that Micah’s injuries were so severe that he would no longer be able to model. 

At the end of this week’s episode of ‘Welcome to Plathville,’ viewers got to see the moments leading up to the siblings smackdown, including what– or rather who– ignited the intense exchange.

“Who, ME?!”

After Lydia and Zac said “I do,” Micah and Isaac hung out as Isaac’s girlfriend Kaylynn snapped some silly pics of the two siblings. While the brothers were joking around with one another, Kaylynn expressed to viewers how much fun they were having and how much Micah and Isaac care about each other and “get along.” 

*Loves to beat his face in…

Moments later, though, things started to take a turn. 

As Micah was walking back towards the wedding with Isaac and Kaylynn, Veronica saw him so he walked over to her to talk. According to Micah, Veronica mistakenly believed that the girl walking with him (and Isaac) was their brother Ethan’s girlfriend Teegan– not Kaylynn– which made Veronica angry. 

“She was like, ‘What are you doing up there with that slut?’” Micah recalled, with Isaac telling viewers, “That really, really, really pissed me off.” 

Kaylynn confirmed to viewers that Isaac didn’t take Veronica’s comment very well, claiming that Isaac is “very protective” of her. Isaac adds that he’s “not big on disrespect,” especially when it comes to his family. 

“In Plath Speak, those are fightin’ words. Time to rip someone’s nose off!”

“It’s unacceptable and I think Micah should do something about it, but if not, I will, I guess,” he says. “Because nobody’s gonna sit there and call her that and just get away with it.” 

In the trailer for next week’s episode, we see the morning after Lydia and Zac’s big day, where it’s 7:30 a.m. and Veronica hasn’t heard from Micah since the previous night. She tells viewers that after not receiving a text back from Micah, she ended up checking his location and finding that he was at a hospital. 

“I get a text from Micah, ‘Isaac attacked me over you,’” she later tells viewers. 

“I got my face bashed in, and it’s all your fault!”

This aligns with what Veronica wrote on social media in March. She posted to Reddit that, by the time of the fight, she had already left the wedding and returned to her hotel room. She also claimed that the Plaths didn’t inform her that Micah had been in a fight, or that he had been taken to the hospital. 

“I was asleep at my hotel by then … I called him almost 100 times when I woke up to see his location at a hospital in Florida,” she wrote in March. “I thought he could’ve been shot, or in a car accident. Never in my wildest dreams [did I think he was] nearly beat to death by a family member … .” 

“[Isaac] drunkenly rearranged his face,” Veronica added. “He nearly killed him. His nose was ripped off as well as the leather jacket he wore.”

In the preview clip for the next episode of ‘Welcome to Plathville,’ we get to see footage from the day after the fight.

“I got a text from Micah [that said], ‘Isaac attacked me over you,'” Veronica tells the cameras, adding that Micah told her, “I’ve never seen so much blood” regarding his fight with Isaac. 

She later sits down with several Plaths and argues that the brotherly brawl was not her fault.

“But beatin’ brothers’ faces in is what us Plath men do!”

“I did not control the arms of these two men,” she says, to which Ethan Plath jumps in to inform her that Isaac told Micah that he “lost respect” for him for remaining in a relationship with Veronica. 

“Because of what YOU HAVE DONE!” he stresses. 

New episodes of ‘Welcome to Plathville’ air Tuesdays on TLC. 

RELATED STORY: Lydia Plath Reveals How ‘Welcome to Plathville’ Has Changed Her Siblings, Discusses How She Handles Her Family’s Feuds & More

(Photos: 

35 Responses


  1. They should all be ashamed of themselves for disrespecting their sister Lydia on the biggest day of her life! Veronica is straight up Mean Girl vibes. She is still all over social media milking every drop she can trying to be relevant. Micah should sue her azz. she is spewing all kinds of hateful garbage about him, saying he has herpes 1, which is colds sore on the mouth, but she is saying it trying to make people believe it is the other type. If it was so bad, why would you stay for so long? She is a horrible human being. You do not go to someones wedding and act like that. She should have keapt her flat azz at home and none of that would have happened. Micah should have dumped her a long time ago, the way she talks to him, is just horrible. All I can say is Karma is a dish best served cold and I would serve it with a knuckle sandwich to her evil, vile, lurch looking goonie man body azz.


  2. Micah is a Sweet person who made some mistakes… But Micah, Veronica looks like a man! she’s just a miserable person and wants to make everyone around her miserable… but I guess you can’t help who you love… Every family has some kind of crazy drama like this, it just doesn’t get aired on TV… I like the show and hope it continues😊


  3. I think, given the way they were raised, some of this was foreseeable. Micah and Ethan both picked unstable women, kind of like their mother? Neither of those two women will leave the family alone anytime soon, even if it is just Olivia, feeding Veronica the fuel for her fire against Micah. Jealously is usually a sign that the jealous person doesn’t trust themselves or are damaged to the point they just don’t trust anyone.


  4. Well Ethan needed to get rid of Veronica anyway. She is scary and the way she talked to him, especially in therapy, it was doomed. Sorry about the fight though, seems there may be another Plath who can’t handle drinking.


  5. It is so sad that these two brother let an unstable woman come between them! I only hope that time will heal these wounds and won’t leave a scar on their relationship or on Micah’s gorgeous face!


  6. I may think Veronica is unlikable and her behavior unacceptable, however this is not an excuse for a Issac to beat his brother, especially to the point of breaking his nose. That is criminal and should be treated as such.


    1. Absolutely totally agree. I don’t know what’s got in Isaac since he has a GF now he thinks he’s the man! Bully just like ETHAN.


    2. They were sorta wrestling, like brothers do and Micah started it by flipping him. My brothers and I still wrestle and I am 63. hehehee


  7. I hope Micah’s scar serves as a lifelong reminder of his poor judgment. Still can’t imagine what he ever saw in Veronica. His clear perception of Ethan’s marriage makes it even more baffling.

    Isaac has been fun to watch this season. He definitely has a spine (I noticed that last season) which seems to be a rare trait these days.


  8. They were doing long distance when he cheated on her. He lived in LA and she lived in Florida. She loved him and probably gave him an ultimatum to move in with her or be done, thinking she could stop him from cheating by keeping tabs on him. She is also a realtor so maybe she thought the exposure would be great for business. But anyone who saw her on the show wouldn’t want someone so unstable and unhinged to be responsible for the biggest financial transaction in your life. Its hard to get over being cheated on and it wasn’t just one night and one girl, it was multiple nights and multiple girls. She also had him do a heap of renovations on both of her houses and she saved tens of thousands of dollars. She was also able to humiliate him publicly both on the show, on social media platforms and interviews. It was payback and calculated, in her mind she was funny and clever. Unfortunately it came of as unstable, unhinged, violatile and evil.


  9. What is wrong with the elder Plath brothers?? Are they attracted to unstable, mentally unhinged, ridiculous women!! The time wasted with the two women is a shame!!
    Veronica should be institutionalized!!! I’m very serious! She is not normal! Micah, start thinking with the head that will move you forward in life. Start exercising your voice and your opinions! Look at Ethan!! He is an angry, frustrated, ready to explode, if the situation presents itself, young man!
    Micah, Veronica will NEVER be out of your life. She figures you have a “pay-back” coming to you!! Be careful, truly!! She is unstable!!
    Congratulations and best wishes to Lydia and Zac!!


  10. It’s really hard to defend a Plath, but man alive – Veronica is a very messed up person. She is full of so much hate and I can’t imagine who would want to be around her. It was so bad that it actually overshadowed Lydia’s horrific siblings (& mother). Why on earth did she go to this wedding? Screen time?

    I actually felt bad for Micah. He may be unfaithful and dumb, but he doesn’t seem cruel. She seems cruel and lacking empathy. Girl, I hope you go to therapy and that you get yourself sorted. This ain’t it.


  11. Am I missing something? Micah and Veronica stayed at the cabin owned by the Plaths. They didn’t stay at a hotel. Did Veronica leave the wedding and book a hotel room? Why was Micah in the hospital in FL when the wedding and fight were in GA? There’s a hospital with an emergency room right in Cairo GA. I’m thinking the fight didn’t take place at the reception site like Veronica said it did. And if she’d learn to keep her smart mouth shut and have some class, shit like this wouldn’t happen. I don’t like the Plaths but I like Veronica even less. It’s too bad Kaylyn & Teegan didn’t smack the shit out of Veronica instead of the guys getting into it.


    1. You’re mixing up the proposal and the wedding. It’s possible that the ER in GA couldn’t treat Micah’s injuries and he was transferred to higher tier hospital. I’ve seen nothing indicating that the fight took place anywhere except the reception.


  12. I haven’t watched the show but I did last week because of the lead up and what a sh!t show. The father, oh my, no thank you. The mother and brothers dogging their sister and trying to stage a wedding “intervention” the night before the wedding, good grief. A grown man throwing a tantrum and throwing tables and peeling out at a high rate of speed in a yard full of people, what an unhinged immature fool. The curling iron, whi can forget the curling iron. And Veronica, what a piece of work. She’s rude, nasty, conceited, smug and weird. Who the heck goes to their partner’s sister’wedding, last minutes, with the express purpose of ruining it and making people uncomfortable by feeding cows, calling people names, making unfounded accusations and acting like a total jerk from the moment they arrived. She is completely unlikable. The combination of the jackassery and unlikeable family, it’s a miracle the show still is on the air.


    1. Kim, spreading such ugliness. It’s ironic isn’t it that they’ll all so choose corned about Lydia’s relationship, which is just beautiful and pure, while all of their (the boys) relationships are the most toxic narcissistic nightmares!!! How dare any of them, especially Kim, question Lydia!!!
      Wanting to tell her “this might be the biggest mistake you’ve ever made in your life” while she’s so in love? What mother does that to their daughter? She is seriously f**ked up.
      I think Barry is great and I’m so glad he away from her. I’ve never seen two people so sure about anything!!!


      1. They think Lydia is dumb, she is not. She is the one that was taking a care of the house and the younger girls when Kim was off in her own world. Lydia has always wanted to be married. My brother was the same way and they have been married 40 years.


  13. I truly do not like the Plath’s. Veronica is very unlikeable. She is condescending and rude to everyone around her. Everything that comes out of her mouth sounds like a true smart ass. She acts like the entire world is beneath her.

    She is psychotically jealous. To call Katelyn (who she thought was Teagan) a slut tells you all you need to know about her character. How is walking somehow slutty to her? The thing that made my jaw hit the floor was when Micah said that Veronica said to him about Moriah “I don’t care if she gets killed by a cartel”. Who says that?! They should have broken up a long time ago. She knows Micah is a cheater she chose to stay with him. Micah knows what a cruel and nasty person Veronica is and he chose to stay with her. I don’t have sympathy for either.

    Micah getting stitches for a broken nose is hardly being beaten to death. Micah going to the ER to get stitches is not being admitted and hospitalized. His nose was not “ripped off”. Why exaggerate so much? Because Veronica likes the drama and chaos she causes.


    1. You can see that over the season the light has gone from Micah’s eyes. She has sucked his soul out of him. She thinks she is smart but a real smart person can understand others views. Loved how last night she was ” I will show you when I get my phone” and then later it is right in her pocket and she gets called out and could not prove one of her lies. Finally, so glad they broke up.


  14. Idk why Veronica even stayed with Micah. She couldn’t forgive him for cheating on her and she hates his whole family. The Plaths are a messed up family but Veronica might be more messed up that them.

Leave a Reply to Shady Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share the Post:

Related Posts