Kenny Santucci says he still gets hate for the sexual assault allegations made against him in 2011 by Tonya Cooley, his castmate on ‘The Challenge,’ but now says he sees the lawsuit and its aftermath in a new light.
During a new interview with the Challenge Mania podcast, Kenny explained that, although he still continues to lose opportunities because of the lawsuit, he now believes it happened for a reason— to get him off TV and onto a different career path.
As longtime fans of ‘The Challenge’ will remember, Tonya filed a lawsuit against Kenny and fellow cast member Evan Starkman, as well as MTV and Bunim-Murray Productions, claiming that she was sexually assaulted by Kenny and Evan while filming ‘The Challenge: The Ruins’ in 2009.
In the lawsuit, Tonya claimed that she got drunk and passed out in ‘The Challenge’ house one night and that Evan and Kenny proceeded to take off her bikini top and squirt lotion on her, before taking another male castmate’s toothbrush and rubbing it around and inside of her genitals, all while producers watched and cameras rolled.
Kenny and Evan have always maintained that they did not commit the crimes Tonya accused them of, but the pair still received a permanent ban from the show. MTV settled the lawsuit with Tonya for an undisclosed amount of money and all parties were barred from talking about it.
Despite the fact that the lawsuit was settled more than a decade ago, Kenny says it still affects his career to this day.
“The amount of opportunities that I lost through all the f**king ‘Challenge’ s**t… still to this day, there are opportunities where they go, ‘You know, we found this thing on the Internet,'” Kenny told hosts Scott Yager and Derrick Kosinski. “And I go, ‘There was nothing to it. I was never in court. I never paid a f**king dollar.'”
@mtvooch Kenny Santucci finally speaks and says “NO ONE TOUCHED THIS GIRL” IN REGARDS TO THE TONYA SITUATION! HOW DO YOU FEEL ABOUT IT? #thechallenge42 #zachnicholspodcast #johnnybananas #caramaria #mtvthechallenge ♬ original sound – MTVOOCH
The former reality star says that people hold on to the fact that he and Evan–through MTV— chose to settle the lawsuit.
“It’s like, if I say, ‘Hey, these two guys touched me,’ your attorneys are gonna be like, ‘How much is he asking for? $10 grand? Give him the f**king $10 grand and end it. Because if it goes any further, it’s going to cost you $60 grand.’ That’s how the legal system works.”
Kenny clarified that, while he didn’t have to pay Tonya any money over her claims, MTV and the show’s production did.
“Bunim-Murray was like, ‘Shut the f**k up, we’re just gonna pay for everything and then move on with your life.'”
He went on to, once again, deny that he ever assaulted Tonya.
“It’s always like the ‘Challenge’ fans who are like, ‘Could you believe what he did [to Tonya]?’ And I’m like, ‘No one touched this girl! I swear as Christ hangs on the cross, may God strike me dead right now and kill everyone in my family.”
Kenny then asked Derrick— who was in the house on the night the alleged assault took place— if he saw anyone “touch this broad.”
Derrick denied seeing anything go down.
“Was it a joke that went wrong? Sure. Whatever,” Kenny said. “What were we, 25 at the time? Hang me on that cross. But…you get to a point where you have to realize this happened for a reason. And I have to take full responsibility for that. I have to take ownership. We were f**king drinking, we were hanging out, we were telling stupid jokes. It was the times, I’ll take full responsibility for everything.”
The podcast hosts noted that Kenny is now more willing to talk about what happened, something Kenny attributed to him trying to learn from the experience.
View this post on Instagram
“Now I have to realize: what does this teach me?” Kenny said, adding that Tonya is the only person who has made claims against him like this.
“It was one person, you know what? It happened for a reason. It got me out of doing television and put me on this other track. Maybe I’m met to help other people in another way,” he said.
Kenny— who, earlier this year, spoke about being suicidal after the lawsuit broke in 2011— called getting banned from ‘The Challenge’ “a dark time,” but insists he used to it better himself in the fitness arena. (He also hosts the Strong New York podcast.)
View this post on Instagram
“I am OK with it, and whatever people are saying [about the lawsuit] I’m OK with,” he said. “But still to this day, I know nothing happened…all the people who were there said it didn’t happen. It’s all a bunch of people who weren’t there who are like, ‘Oh, this happened!'”
Kenny went on to give his thoughts on ‘cancel culture,’ something he experienced before it was an actual thing.
“Since like 2020 I feel like the world has shifted so much, into this, like, cancel culture. And people want to cancel you no matter who you are…everyone has been f**king cancelled at this point. Society forces you into like, ‘you need to pick a side’ and no matter what you say, you are f**ked. So you might as well say what you want.”
In February, Kenny appeared on the Rare in NY podcast and reflected on being “cancelled,” calling it, “one of the hardest things I’ve ever had to deal with.”
He also discussed how badly Tonya’s lawsuit affected him.
“ … I literally wanted to f**king kill myself,” Kenny claimed. “And I’m like, if this happens, then I lose. So, I needed to figure out what could keep me going, what could keep me happy … so maybe one day, if I do get the chance to tell my story, it’s like, maybe there’s probably somebody else who could benefit from it. So for me, it was a lot of like, ‘Okay, how do I get beyond this?’”
Tonya has never discussed the lawsuit and left life in the public eye after the incident.
You can listen to Kenny’s full interview with the Challenge Mania podcast here.
RELATED STORY: Former ‘Challenge’ Star Kenny Santucci Claims He Was Suicidal After Sexual Assault Lawsuit Involving Tonya Cooley
18 Responses
Johnny banana was the worst. He walked around with a blow up doll doing sex acts to it. He assaulted and antagonized Carmella and that girl on the show where couples competed. Plus he was a bully to Sara on that show.
Gross liar go away. Believe Tonya
Can Kenny explain what “the joke” was exactly?
I believe Tonya.
“Was it a joke that went wrong? Sure. Whatever.” So did not do it or was it a joke that went wrong?
As someone who enjoyed attention and called himself “Mr. Beautiful,” I find it hard to believe that Kenny is at peace with the lost opportunities to be in the spotlight on tv.
What I do think is unfair is how he and Evan are the only ones being singled out, when there are other cast mates that engaged in similar problematic behaviors…
Didn’t Rachel, Tina, and Veronica photograph Tonya while she was passed out naked and share the photos with the other cast mates, while taunting and making fun of her? Some of these women were the WORST. Suzie comes to mind as well. Perhaps her buddy Sarah too.
On top of his displays of extremely violent and psychotic behavior, CT dogged several women out. I felt bad for Anastasia/Birdy. Production and CT made sure to put a spin on it and make her look like a ho-bag for falling for his charms. He played toxic games with other women to include Dee, but we like re-write history and romanticize their story, just because of a few endearing moments that were had. I’m disgusted by the CT in older episodes, yet here we are in 2026, and women are still drooling over him and willing to forget his past because he’s still hot and has a new image, I guess…
When I re-watched RW Austin, I was taken aback by how Wes and Nehemiah teamed up and both got in their female roommates face of a female cast mate, much like Tony did to Camilla that season that they got kicked off for fighting. I mean these guys were both physically intimidating this woman and screaming in her face, yet no one ever mentions it, because they became icons/the darlings of the Challenge.
Johnny Bananas was also calling women “dumb bitch” and what not….
Preach.
I don’t know how JB isn’t buried in shame by their audience.
Ok, first, Kenny—I hate that you reached such a dark place in your mental health that you considered ending your life. That’s gotta be a terrible feeling.
But…..you experienced consequences because you treated Tonya, and other female cast members, deplorably. We watched your sad frat boy douchebag antics and the complete lack of respect you showed women for multiple seasons. Maybe you didn’t use a toothbrush to violate Tonya but you definitely treated her poorly.
I hope in the last 15 years you have learned to treat women well and with respect and decency. And I think leaving reality tv was for the best. Who knows how much more you would have shown your foolishness had you been permitted to stay.
He wasn’t the only one guilty of that though, and women are still drooling over some of those douchebags, while overlooking their pasts. Not saying I’m a fan of the behavior, just pointing out the hypocrisy. Some of those douche bags even displayed physical intimidation towards women.
Who is being hypocritical? MTV demonstrated it is willing to overlook disgusting behavior as long as there aren’t any lawsuits. That’s all the companies really care about at the end of the day.
I remember in one season how Theresa had a crush on both Kenny and Wes but didn’t know who she wanted more. She hooked up with Wes then and he was going on and on about how he got his “sloppy seconds”.
You mean the season where Theresa was very drunk, asked Kenny to get in bed with her and he said no because she was drunk? Then he put her to bed and left the room. If you’re telling it, tell it all.
Who’s Theresa?
Absolutely disgusted by this guy. He is not the victim!
Of course he acts like he was a teenager just doing guy stuff when he was actually a 25 year old man. That’s a fully grown adult. I’m glad this has followed him. Maybe in another 15 years, he’ll actually be willing to have some accountability. For him to deny touching her when he was filmed is certainly audacious. I hope this interview violates the terms of the settlement. He deserves that.
I just watched a ton of challenge episodes and seasons this summer and it always surprises me to see how long ago it was filmed because he really looks older
Aww…gee…poor Kenny still gets hate for sexually assaulting someone.🙄
I believe wholeheartedly that he did it. Evan and Kenny were HORRIBLE to women on that show. Sexually inappropriate is putting it mildly. They felt like they were entitled to do what they did. And the fact that MTV kept the cameras rolling is sickening. FYI if cameras were rolling I’m sure they got it ON CAMERA so why bother with the denial?
And listening to him I see he hasn’t changed and will never care to understand the gravity of what he did.
Sorry, Kenny. Everyone who watched the show saw what you did. Kenny and Evan should have been criminally prosecuted for what they did to Tanya. Tanya was a sloppy drunk, that much is true, but no one — drunk, sober, high, etc. — should be sexually assaulted the way Kenny and Evan did to her. They thought it was funny to rape her with a toothbrush while she was passed out. They thought they were cool. Kenny was an arrogant, misogynistic ass to a lot of the female cast members, so he’s full of shit that he never did anything.
Unfortunately, what they were accused of wasn’t illegal in Thailand.