‘Unexpected’ Stars Hailey “Hailey 2” Tilford & Matthew Blevins Hint at Possible Break Up a Week After Announcing They’re Expecting a Baby Together

Gee, this looked so promising…

Unexpected couple Matthew Blevins and Hailey “Hailey 2” Tilford announced they’re expecting a baby together just one week ago; however, it seems the happy couple may not be getting their fairytale ending after all.

According to Starcasm, Matthew and Hailey 2 hinted on Instagram this weekend that their relationship may be over, beginning with Hailey 2 posting a sonogram photo captioned with “I got this, Doing it ALL for you baby boy.”

Matthew — who is already a father to daughter Kinsley, whom he shares with another ‘Unexpected’ star, Hailey Thomlinson (aka the OG Hailey) — appeared to confirm the breakup speculation by sharing a post from one of his followers commenting on the social media reaction to the breakup rumors.


“Y’all got sit here & laugh at Hailey & Matthew breaking up because half of you ‘called it’ but they’re hurting & upset & they have a kid on the way,” the poster wrote (and Matthew reposted). “You’re all so quick to sit and judge and talk s**t just because why you saw on a TV SHOW. [Grow] up and look at the whole picture, maybe they’re just on a break or something. But whatever the reason is isn’t our f**king business & y’all bullying her is total s**t. Grow the f**k up. She’s got a baby on the way & she may need someone to talk to. Stop picking bits and pieces to talk s**t about when it’s NOT our lives.” 

At the moment, Hailey 2 and Matthew continue to follow each other on social media, despite Hailey 2 having wiped her Instagram of nearly all photos featuring Matthew. The pregnancy announcements from Matthew and Hailey 2 remain on their respective accounts as well. 


Hailey 1 has yet to comment on Matthew and Hailey 2’s possible split.

Unfortunately we won’t get to see if Matthew manages to knock up a third Hailey by the end of next season…

According to Starcasm, Matthew and Hailey 2 will not return to ‘Unexpected’ next season. 

RELATED STORY: ‘Unexpected’ Star Hailey “Hailey 2” Tilford is Pregnant with Matthew Blevins’ Second Child: See Their Announcement 

(Photos: TLC, Instagram) 


  1. OMG! This was too funny! This is what you get for naming your daughters’ Hailey. If you had named them something respectable they would have had higher standards.

  2. What do these girls see in him? I know it is not all about looks but he could pass fir Adam Driver’s ugly pimple infested younger brother.

  3. Whatever town they live in must have a male population In the single digits. It’s the only explanation for any female wanting to be with him, let alone two.

  4. This guy will probably find some other dumb teenage girl to inseminate before the end of the month! I don’t understand how though?? I can barely understand him speak…..

  5. serves her right for acting so cocky at the tell all – she deserves to be haunted by her foolishness for the rest of her life

  6. I want to vomit when I think about these skinny little goofy looking KIDS having sex. Ewwww!!!!!!! I remember in high school thinking high school boys looked like……boys.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.