Jay Manuel Addresses His “Uncomfortable” Moments on ‘America’s Next Top Model’: Says He Was “Scared to Speak Up” While Filming Controversial Scenes

Surprisingly not one of the uncomfortable moments to which Jay is referring.

Jay Manuel, former Creative Director of America’s Next Top Model, is spilling the tea about his time on the reality competition show and revealing that it wasn’t always something to smize about.

In a recent interview with Variety, Jay said that, despite serving as the show’s creative director, he was often “scared to speak up” during “uncomfortable” moments – some of which recently went viral.

Earlier this month, show creator/head judge Tyra Banks was called out on social media after problematic vintage ‘ANTM’ clips (including a photoshoot featuring contestants in blackface) resurfaced on social media. Tyra commented on social media about a week after the controversy began, calling some of the moments “really off choices.” She doesn’t appear to have commented further on the issue at this point.


After Tyra issued her statement, Variety reports that ’ANTM’ co-creator Ken Mok added his own, admitting that he will now look “at some of those moments and cringe.” However, Ken went on to take some of the heat off of Tyra, telling his followers that “the entire creative team made the choices on those shows – not just Tyra.”

In his recent interview, though, Jay denied Ken’s claim and argued that, while the team was able to voice their creative concerns, Tyra and Ken made all of the final decisions as to what happened on the show.

“Many times when you’re working in an environment like that, you have to listen to your executive producers and ultimately the two voices at the top were Ken and Tyra,” Jay said. “There were sometimes several objections by other producers and myself about layers that were added to creative and we were just told to execute. I think it’s a little unfair to throw the whole team under the bus. The whole team wasn’t really supported, so to speak.”

Raise your hand if you want absolutely nothing to do with this drama…

Jay also noted there were certain people working on the show in senior positions that caused others (including several producers) to become “very scared to speak up.”  

In response to Jay’s statement, Ken responded, noting that Jay was “involved in many creative decisions throughout his time with the show” but admitting that “the ultimate decisions always rested with us, the creative directors of the show, and we continue to take full responsibility.”

Jay elaborated further on the backlash Tyra has received during an episode of Jays Chat, a weekly Instagram Live show he co-hosts with Miss J. Alexander (who also appeared on ‘ANTM’ for many years.) During the live stream, the former ‘ANTM’ stars break down previous seasons of the show and reveal behind-the-scenes secrets. While discussing Cycle 4, the recent criticism was addressed and Jay opened up about the blame being placed on Tyra.

“ … I really do think Tyra is being thrown under the bus unfairly but I’ll be honest … at the same time, like, I can’t defend her,” Jay said. “I can’t get inside her head of what she meant. This cycle a lot of very controversial things happened and I’m just gonna stipulate this guys, everyone keeps asking, ‘Well who allowed that? Oh but the Jays stood by and let this happen.’ And this and this and this and that.’ Okay, let’s be real. It was Tyra, as she always says in the press, it was her show. It was her show, she was the host … .”

Jay went on to reveal that Cycle 4 was the first season that Ken and Tyra started doing “the huddles” which changed his role, creatively speaking. Regarding his duty to fulfill his role as creative director for the controversial “ethnicity swap holding babies” shoot, Jay said it’s why he has “PTSD from this season.” (You can check out a scene from that episode below.)

“ … I don’t know what Tyra’s response was to the initial backlash, I know she explained it had nothing to do with racism, it had something to do with understanding other races. I don’t want to quote her, I don’t even remember,” Jay said. “But I just remember this being very uncomfortable for me. But what could I do? Like, I couldn’t walk … I couldn’t not be there was the problem. I don’t even remember if I said something on camera, but they, you know, they edit the show, so I don’t even remember what I said that day.”

Jay said people rediscover the episode “every two years” and “try to cancel Tyra online, which I think is crazy.”

“ … She has an answer but you guys have to ask her what her reason was,” he continued. “I don’t know what her reason was, I just know I was a little uncomfortable with it because it didn’t fly then – you guys keep saying it wouldn’t fly today, it didn’t fly then … .”

In addition to speaking out about his time on ‘ANTM’, Jay has written a novel inspired by the people in his life, including a certain former boss.

At least he didn’t make her last name “Vault” or “Safety de Posit-Box.”

Jay’s upcoming book, The Wig The Bitch & The Meltdown, is described as a “satirical look behind the scenes of Model Muse, a fictional, reality model competition show and global phenomenon.” The book reportedly tells a tale of “ambition, jealously, blackmail, mystery and revenge” through the eyes of the story’s “moral compass, Pablo Michaels.” The host of the fictional model reality competition show featured in the story is a character by the name of Keisha Kash.


As if the character names, cover font and promotional video don’t blur the lines between reality and fiction enough, a chapter titled “The Meltdown” features Keisha Kash losing it on one of the contestants, á la Tyra Banks. And yes, Jay admits the chapter was inspired by the famous “we were rooting for you!” scene from Cycle 4.

“That’s my move, Keisha!”

Jay said Tyra was not consulted about the book, nor were any of his former ‘ANTM’ colleagues. In fact, he says he doesn’t have much of a relationship with Tyra at all these days. Aside from emails “over the past few years,” he said the last time he and Tyra ran into each other was in 2017.

“To be very honest, we really have no relationship to speak of, which is really sad,” he said.

While it would seem that “no relationship” constitutes a bad relationship, Jay gave Tyra a shout out on social media just last month, calling her his “#WCW.”

“We may no longer speak every day or see each other often, but this woman to my right taught me some of the biggest lessons life has to offer,” Jay wrote. “Self-validation is the ONLY thing that allows you to conquer your #fears & achieve your #dreams.”

In response to one of his followers asking why he and Tyra no longer follow each other on social media, Jay simply replied, “it’s complicated.”

Jay’s book, The Wig, The Bitch & The Meltdown, comes out August 3 and is currently available for pre-order.

You can watch the entire YouTube episode of Jays Chat, in which both ‘ANTM’ Jays talk about the controversy, below! 

RELATED STORY: Tyra Banks Responds After Problematic Clips From ‘America’s Next Top Model’ Showing Racism & Cruelty Go Viral

(Photos:Instagram; Twitter; UPN; JayManuel.com)


  1. Back in the day people were not really allowed to have their own opinion or it was suppressed. I think it was Jay Manuel who said to Cassandra (cycle 4?) “Cut your hair or get out of here.” or something of the sort. It was just about the show and how watched it will be…etc. Not to mention MOST of the photo shoots had nothing to do with modeling but all with trying to humiliate the contestants in one way or another. It’s not like it’s the only Top Model show that does that, it’s just the only one that is globally known. So yeah, I think it won’t be filmed anymore especially with everything coming to light now. LOL, I remember when they made it for male models too, that’s when I really lost interest, no one wants to see two straight contestants hook up, this is not a dating show!

    1. Omg, I totally forgot when they brought the male models in! You are right that they mostly just humiliated the contestants. And, that they were the best known show. I think Janice Dickinson did some spin off model show back then that was pretty much the same format.

  2. I haven’t watched this in many years and didn’t know it was still on or even airing. I do remember that there was a girl whose best friend had recently died & the photo shoot was to take pictures in a coffin in a freshly dug grave. She was having panic attacks but no one cared including Jay. And, when they would do makeovers some would be great but some would be God awful. Burning scalps, girls shaking & crying from the pain and the Jays taunting them for whining. I had to stop watching this because I didn’t agree in a lot of what they did or in how the contestants bullied each other.

    1. Kahlen Rondot (might have changed her last name now), she was my fave, I remember that episode really clearly. She got called first for it too, she really pulled it off despite everything.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.